%PDF-1.5
%
1 0 obj
<<
/Type /Catalog
/Pages 2 0 R
/Metadata 3 0 R
/Outlines 4 0 R
/PageLabels 5 0 R
>>endobj
3 0 obj
<<
/Type /Metadata
/Length 3361
/Subtype /XML
>>
stream
2017-02-10T18:41:45-10:00
PScript5.dll Version 5.2.2
2017-02-11T13:37:55-10:00
Acrobat Distiller 15.0 (Windows)
application/pdf
Microsoft Word - 679741_1.DOC
wiscja
uuid:17bcd01c-be84-4c4f-b00b-4e6d0d2f0fc0
uuid:e64e4901-340b-42a3-a7ad-b521f1599b5a
endstream
endobj
22 0 obj
<<
/Length 5603
>>
stream
q
/GS1 gs
BT
/TT2 1 Tf
7.98 0 0 7.98 72 37.8 Tm
0 g
.0002 Tc
0 Tw
(679741_1)Tj
12 0 0 12 107.58 37.8 Tm
14.7572 Tc
( )Tj
/TT4 1 Tf
4.095 58.92 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0025 Tw
(TESTIMONY OF )Tj
0 -1.15 TD
-.001 Tc
.0042 Tw
[(THE DE)-4(PARTMENT OF THE ATTORNE)-4(Y GENERAL)-5.2( )]TJ
0 -1.155 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0025 Tw
[(TWENTY-)-7.3(N)1.9(INTH LEGISLATURE, 2017 )]TJ
18.835 0 TD
.0001 Tc
-.0001 Tw
( )Tj
4.725 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
4.725 0 TD
( )Tj
ET
155.22 713.34 386.28 .23999 re
f
BT
12 0 0 12 156.72 702.24 Tm
( )Tj
0 -1.15 TD
( )Tj
/TT4 1 Tf
-7.06 -1.155 TD
-.0002 Tc
.0024 Tw
[(ON THE FOLLOWIN)7(G)-2.4( MEASURE: )]TJ
/TT2 1 Tf
0 -1.145 TD
.0003 Tc
.0019 Tw
(H.B. NO.)Tj
/TT4 1 Tf
4.005 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
.28 0 TD
-.0005 Tc
.001 Tw
(407, RELATING TO INSURANCE.)Tj
/TT4 1 Tf
15.325 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
-19.61 -1.15 TD
( )Tj
/TT4 1 Tf
0 -1.155 TD
-.0005 Tc
.0027 Tw
[(BEFORE T)-4.7(H)1.7(E: )]TJ
/TT2 1 Tf
0 -1.145 TD
-.0009 Tc
.0018 Tw
(HOUSE COMMITTEES ON HEALTH A)Tj
17.43 0 TD
-.0008 Tc
.003 Tw
(ND ON INTERSTATE COMMERCE )Tj
-17.43 -1.15 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
/TT4 1 Tf
T*
-.0018 Tc
[(DATE:)-8.8( )]TJ
/TT2 1 Tf
6.5 0 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0008 Tw
(Tuesday, February 14, 2017 )Tj
/TT4 1 Tf
16 0 TD
.0004 Tc
0 Tw
(TIME:)Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
2.725 0 TD
0 Tc
.0005 Tw
( 8:30 a.m. )Tj
/TT4 1 Tf
-25.225 -1.725 TD
.0002 Tc
0 Tw
(LOCATION: )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
6.5 0 TD
-.0004 Tc
.0026 Tw
(State Capitol, Room 329 )Tj
/TT4 1 Tf
-6.5 -1.725 TD
0 Tw
(TESTIFIER\(S\): )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
9 0 TD
0 Tc
.0022 Tw
(Douglas S. Chin, Attorney General, or )Tj
-9 -1.15 TD
-.0001 Tc
.0023 Tw
[( )-6220( )-2220(Daniel K. Jacob, D)]TJ
17.28 0 TD
-.0002 Tc
-.0001 Tw
(eputy Attorney General )Tj
-17.28 -1.155 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
70.5 519.42 471 .72003 re
f
BT
12 0 0 12 72 508.32 Tm
( )Tj
0 -1.15 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0025 Tw
(Chairs Belatti and Ohno and )Tj
12.84 0 TD
.0001 Tc
.0004 Tw
(Members of the Committees: )Tj
-9.84 -1.725 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0012 Tw
(The Department of the A)Tj
10.95 0 TD
-.0005 Tc
.0002 Tw
[(ttorney General prov)-5.5(ides)]TJ
10.945 0 TD
0 Tc
.0022 Tw
( the following comments )Tj
-24.895 -1.725 TD
-.0001 Tc
.0023 Tw
(regarding legal concerns about this bill. )Tj
T*
-.0007 Tc
.0021 Tw
[( )-2720.8(The purpos)-5.7(e of this bill is to facilit)-7.9(at)]TJ
18.565 0 TD
-.0004 Tc
.0026 Tw
[(e the establis)-5.4(hment of health plans that )]TJ
-18.565 -1.725 TD
.0025 Tw
(qualify as high deductible health plans in Ha)Tj
19.515 0 TD
-.0006 Tc
.0028 Tw
(waii, which may be purchased for use with )Tj
-19.515 -1.725 TD
-.0004 Tc
.0026 Tw
(a health savings account and which allow the )Tj
20.29 0 TD
.0025 Tw
(labor force to receive contributions to )Tj
-20.29 -1.725 TD
0 Tc
.0013 Tw
(health savings accounts. Initially, we not)Tj
18.065 0 TD
-.0002 Tc
.0011 Tw
(e that the terms "st)Tj
8.36 0 TD
-.0007 Tc
.0029 Tw
(and-alone high deductible )Tj
-26.425 -1.725 TD
-.0004 Tc
.0026 Tw
[(plan" and ")-5.4(s)-.4(tand-alone health savings accoun)]TJ
20.22 0 TD
-.0002 Tc
.0011 Tw
(t," as found on Page )Tj
9.31 0 TD
-.0001 Tc
.0023 Tw
(2, lines 20-21, are )Tj
-29.53 -1.725 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0025 Tw
(unclear and should be defined. )Tj
T*
0 Tc
.0022 Tw
[( )-2720(Perhaps more importantly, we want to )]TJ
20.065 0 TD
-.0007 Tc
.0029 Tw
[(advise the Legisla)-4.5(t)-2.9(ure that this bill may be )]TJ
-20.065 -1.725 TD
0 Tc
.0022 Tw
(subject to an Employee Retirement Income )Tj
19.4 0 TD
-.0002 Tc
.0024 Tw
(Security Act \(ERISA\) preemption challenge. )Tj
-19.4 -1.725 TD
-.0001 Tc
.0014 Tw
(Subsection \(b\), of the new section being )Tj
18.065 0 TD
.0023 Tw
[(added to article 10A, chapter 431, H)7.1(a)1.1(waii )]TJ
-18.065 -1.725 TD
-.0004 Tc
.0026 Tw
[(Revise)-4.2(d Statutes, by section )]TJ
12.895 0 TD
-.0009 Tc
.0023 Tw
[(2 of the bill on p)-4.7(age 2, lines)-5.9( )]TJ
12.455 0 TD
-.0002 Tc
.0024 Tw
(10-15, on its face appears )Tj
-25.35 -1.725 TD
-.0005 Tc
.0027 Tw
(directed at insurance entities )Tj
13.005 0 TD
-.0004 Tc
.0026 Tw
(and is placed within the insur)Tj
12.84 0 TD
0 Tc
.0012 Tw
(ance code. However, it may )Tj
-25.845 -1.725 TD
-.0004 Tc
.0026 Tw
(be interpreted as requiring an employer)Tj
ET
232.14 202.56 49.32 .89999 re
f
BT
12 0 0 12 281.46 204.72 Tm
.0025 Tw
[( to offer an empl)6.9(oyee two plans, which may fall )]TJ
-17.455 -1.725 TD
-.0005 Tc
.0027 Tw
[(outside ERISA's insur)-7.5(ance savings clause. )]TJ
T*
-.0003 Tc
.0016 Tw
[( )-2720.9(Furthermore, the risk of an ERISA preem)]TJ
21.175 0 TD
-.0005 Tc
.0027 Tw
(ption challenge may arise because the )Tj
-21.175 -1.72 TD
-.0008 Tc
.0035 Tw
[(purpose of the bill as p)-4.6(r)-2.8(ovided on Page 1, lin)]TJ
19.74 0 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0025 Tw
(es 1-5, indicates an )Tj
8.95 0 TD
-.0002 Tc
-.0001 Tw
(attempt to regulate )Tj
-28.69 -1.725 TD
-.0003 Tc
.005 Tw
(employee welfare benefit )Tj
11.4 0 TD
.0025 Tw
(plans by providing, "[t]he purpose of)Tj
15.92 0 TD
.0004 Tc
.0018 Tw
[( thi)7.6(s).4( Act is to)6.5( facilitate the )]TJ
-27.32 -1.725 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0025 Tw
[(establishm)-7.3(ent of health plans that qualify as)]TJ
19.4 0 TD
.0026 Tw
[( high deduc)-5.4(tible health plans in Hawaii and )]TJ
-19.4 -1.725 TD
-.0005 Tc
.0027 Tw
(may be purchased for use with a health savings account and allow the )Tj
/TT6 1 Tf
31.35 0 TD
.0001 Tc
.0021 Tw
(labor force)Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
4.725 0 TD
.0011 Tc
.0011 Tw
( to )Tj
ET
/Cs6 cs 1 1 1 scn
66.03 745.05 81.3 27.12 re
f
0 0 0 scn
q
81.36 0 0 27.18 66 745.02 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
1 1 1 scn
66.03 717.87 81.3 27.12 re
f
0 0 0 scn
q
81.36 0 0 27.18 66 717.84 cm
/Im2 Do
Q
1 1 1 scn
66.03 690.75 81.3 27.06 re
f
0 0 0 scn
q
81.36 0 0 27.12 66 690.72 cm
/Im3 Do
Q
Q
endstream
endobj
23 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 415
>>
stream
xuSIn@1
<zBC9a7[c@Xh[^˦kqbe 1ru_gV;Je,'F7@ޤ \pV}TB2kSTytWP jڠjq؞|P;c#[Fד
dWJVn:rFy4=P/Hd:^s˲ZݕG,ȖO#sŃ<,cJߺw%ZnFV7ͱ]}d.S6c{^|#BmUhf-~r8azL)3;4"cc_X
endstream
endobj
25 0 obj
<<
/Length 4799
>>
stream
q
/GS1 gs
BT
/TT2 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 726.9 Tm
0 g
.0001 Tc
.0021 Tw
(Testimony of the Department )Tj
13.18 0 TD
-.0006 Tc
.0011 Tw
(of the Attorney General )Tj
-13.18 -1.15 TD
-.0001 Tc
.0023 Tw
(Twenty-Ninth Legislature, 2017 )Tj
T*
-.0007 Tc
.0029 Tw
(Page 2 of 2 )Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
T*
( )Tj
7.98 0 0 7.98 72 37.8 Tm
.0002 Tc
(679741_1)Tj
12 0 0 12 107.58 37.8 Tm
14.7572 Tc
( )Tj
-2.965 51.675 TD
-.0002 Tc
.0024 Tw
(receive contributions to health savings acco)Tj
19.345 0 TD
-.0004 Tc
.0009 Tw
(unts." \(Emphasis added.)Tj
11.135 0 TD
0 Tc
(\) In addition, the )Tj
-30.48 -1.725 TD
-.0007 Tc
.0034 Tw
[(purpose of the bill as p)-4.5(r)-2.7(ovided on Page 1, lin)-4.5(es )]TJ
21.075 0 TD
-.0005 Tc
.0027 Tw
[(10-13, also provide)-4.3(s)-.5( that, the "Act shall )]TJ
-21.075 -1.725 TD
-.0006 Tc
.004 Tw
[(be liberally construed to allow )]TJ
/TT6 1 Tf
13.395 0 TD
.0001 Tc
.0021 Tw
[(employers and em)8.1(ploy)-4.9(ees)]TJ
/TT2 1 Tf
11.675 0 TD
.0006 Tc
.0016 Tw
[( to receive max)5.6(i)2.8(mum tax)5.6( )]TJ
-25.07 -1.725 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0025 Tw
(benefits provided in federal or state law thr)Tj
18.845 0 TD
.0026 Tw
(ough use of a high deductible health plan." )Tj
-18.845 -1.725 TD
-.0001 Tc
.0023 Tw
(\(Emphasis added.\) )Tj
T*
-.0004 Tc
.0042 Tw
[( )-2718.4(ERISA is a comprehensive )]TJ
15.175 0 TD
-.0002 Tc
.0024 Tw
(federal legislative scheme )Tj
11.785 0 TD
(that "supersede[s] any and )Tj
-26.96 -1.725 TD
(all State laws insofar as they may now or her)Tj
19.845 0 TD
0 Tc
-.0003 Tw
(eafter relate to any em)Tj
10.005 0 TD
-.0002 Tc
.004 Tw
(ployee benefit plan." )Tj
-29.85 -1.725 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0025 Tw
(29 U.S.C.A. 1144\(a\).)Tj
7.98 0 0 7.98 193.38 518.52 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(1)Tj
12 0 0 12 197.82 513 Tm
-.0002 Tc
.0024 Tw
( Because the stated purpose of )Tj
14.405 0 TD
-.0003 Tc
[(the bill appears to be di)6.9(rected )]TJ
-24.89 -1.725 TD
.0026 Tw
[(to employee welfare benefit plans)-5.4( and laws re)]TJ
20.285 0 TD
-.0002 Tc
.0024 Tw
(lating to employee welfare benefit plans )Tj
-20.285 -1.725 TD
-.0004 Tc
.0026 Tw
(would be preempted by ERISA, this bill c)Tj
18.06 0 TD
-.0005 Tc
.0027 Tw
(ould be preempted by ER)Tj
11.34 0 TD
0 Tc
.0005 Tw
(ISA. This bill, )Tj
-29.4 -1.725 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0025 Tw
(however, may be saved through the insurance )Tj
20.795 0 TD
-.0005 Tc
.0027 Tw
(savings clause found within ERISA that )Tj
-20.795 -1.725 TD
-.0002 Tc
.0011 Tw
(permits states to regulate the )Tj
13.175 0 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0025 Tw
(business of insurance, regardle)Tj
13.89 0 TD
.0003 Tc
.0019 Tw
[(ss of its direct or i)7.5(n)1.5(direct )]TJ
-27.065 -1.725 TD
-.0004 Tc
.0026 Tw
(effect on employee benefit plans)Tj
14.4 0 TD
0 Tc
.0022 Tw
[(. 29 U.S.C)7.2(.)-2.2( 1144\(b\)\(2\)\(A\). )]TJ
/TT6 1 Tf
13.12 0 TD
-.0041 Tc
0 Tw
(See)Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
1.77 0 TD
0 Tc
( )Tj
/TT6 1 Tf
.28 0 TD
-.0005 Tc
.0027 Tw
(Kentucky Ass'n of )Tj
-29.57 -1.725 TD
-.0004 Tc
.0013 Tw
[(Health Pla)-4.2(n).8(s, Inc. v. Miller)]TJ
/TT2 1 Tf
11.555 0 TD
.0001 Tc
.0021 Tw
(, 538 U.S. 329, 342 \(2003\). )Tj
-11.555 -1.72 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0025 Tw
[( )-2720(Our comments above equally apply to secti)]TJ
22.115 0 TD
.0015 Tw
(on 3 of the bill st)Tj
7.285 0 TD
-.0006 Tc
.0011 Tw
(arting on Page 4. )Tj
-29.4 -1.725 TD
-.0002 Tc
.0024 Tw
[( )-2720(Althoug)-4(h we are not recommending that )]TJ
21.02 0 TD
-.001 Tc
.0032 Tw
[(this bill be he)-4.8(ld)-4.8( on legal gr)-8(ounds, we )]TJ
-21.02 -1.725 TD
-.0001 Tc
.0003 Tw
(want the committee to be inform)Tj
14.23 0 TD
-.0004 Tc
.0026 Tw
(ed of the possible legal risk. )Tj
-14.23 -1.725 TD
-.0001 Tc
.0014 Tw
[( )-2720.9(Thank you for the opportunity to comment. )]TJ
/TT8 1 Tf
0 -10.075 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
72 187.68 144 .59999 re
f
BT
12 0 0 12 216 185.16 Tm
( )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
7.98 0 0 7.98 72 176.82 Tm
(1)Tj
/TT8 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 76.44 171.3 Tm
( )Tj
/TT2 1 Tf
.25 0 TD
-.0002 Tc
.0024 Tw
[(The subsection, in full, provides as follows:)-7.4( )]TJ
-.62 -1.15 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
T*
-.0004 Tc
.0026 Tw
[( )-2720( )-2720(Exc)-5.4(ept as provided in subsection \(b\) of)]TJ
23.235 0 TD
-.0001 Tc
.0014 Tw
( this section, the provisions of this )Tj
-20.235 -1.15 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0025 Tw
[(subchapter)-7.3( and subchapter III of this c)]TJ
16.955 0 TD
-.0006 Tc
.0028 Tw
[(hapter shall super)-7.6(sede any and all State )]TJ
-16.955 -1.15 TD
-.0003 Tc
.0017 Tw
[(laws ins)-5.3(o).9(far as they may now or herea)]TJ
17.06 0 TD
0 Tc
.0022 Tw
(fter relate to any employee benefit plan )Tj
-17.06 -1.15 TD
-.0001 Tc
.0023 Tw
(described in section 1003\(a\) of this titl)Tj
16.785 0 TD
-.0005 Tc
.0027 Tw
[(e and not exempt under section 1003\(b\))-7.5( of )]TJ
-16.785 -1.15 TD
-.0001 Tc
.0023 Tw
(this title. This section shall take effect on January 1, 1975. )Tj
/TT8 1 Tf
-3 -1.145 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
26 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 8
>>
stream
x
endstream
endobj
28 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 826
>>
stream
HUn0+(DEI@4-'VEnq[X\fyog